SAFEGUARD REJECTED: Commons debate puts taxi and PHV charges at heart of airport road fee dispute

MPs rejected a proposed safeguard against airport road charges being used to influence travel choices, after a debate specifically raised the prospect of fees affecting taxi and private hire vehicle drivers.
The Commons Public Bill Committee voted 8 to 4 on 17 November against New Clause 3 to the Highways (Financing) Bill. The clause would have barred a licence holder controlling access to an airport from using road user charging under the Bill to meet surface access targets, including targets to reduce journeys by taxi or private hire vehicle (PHV).
Moving the clause, Conservative transport spokesman Greg Smith asked the Government to assure the committee that “private car, taxi and private hire drivers will not be charged under Bill to help an airport to meet its other, entirely separate policy goals”.
Smith said the proposed restriction was intended to prevent tolls on roads built under the Bill from being “inflated or engineered” to change how passengers travelled to an airport. He argued that charges could be used to affect passengers arriving in their own vehicles or being dropped off by someone else.
Transport minister Justin Madders said the Bill already prohibited licence holders from using road user charging schemes under Part 3 of the Transport Act 2000 on a licensed highway. He said the clause was unnecessary, adding that the Bill’s provisions already prevented the action Smith described.
Madders distinguished tolls, which he said paid for road construction and maintenance, from road user charging, which could be used to change travel behaviour. He described a deterrent charge as one intended to persuade people to use alternative transport.
Smith remained concerned that an airport operator could inflate a toll to influence passenger travel. Madders called that “an extremely unlikely set of circumstances” and said the Bill required charging to be balanced against road users’ interests.
The division rejected the clause, with four Conservative MPs voting in favour and eight Labour MPs voting against. The debate centred on whether the Bill needed an additional explicit safeguard covering charges that could affect taxi and PHV access to airports.
.jpg)






